Does California Have the Death Penalty? California Death Penalty Laws and Updates

California does have the death penalty as part of its legal system. However, its implementation has been anything but straightforward, influenced by complex legal battles and shifting public opinion over the years. While the death penalty remains in place in California, recent procedural changes have significantly shaped its application.

What is the Death Penalty?

Capital punishment or the death penalty, is a juridical sentence^[1], a type of punishment, according to which an offender is executed by the state. The death penalty in California has been practiced right from when the state was formed in 1851. It has been shifted through a number of legislative amendments as well as undergone subsequent voters’ votes due to the changes in the people’s perception of capital punishment.

Does California Have the Death Penalty? History of the Death Penalty in California

California’s history with the death penalty is marked by numerous legal battles and public discourse^[2]. The state reinstated capital punishment in California in 1978 after a brief moratorium, leading to a surge in death sentences. However, this surge was accompanied by growing concerns about wrongful convictions and racial disparities in sentencing.

Understanding Proposition 34

In 2012, California voters faced Proposition 34^[3], which sought to abolish the death penalty and replace it with life imprisonment without parole. The proposition was narrowly defeated, with approximately 48% voting for abolition. This outcome demonstrated that while there is significant support for reforming capital punishment, many Californians still believe in its necessity.

Understanding Proposition 62

Proposition 62^[4] was another attempt to abolish the death penalty, appearing on the ballot in 2016. Like its predecessor, it aimed to replace capital punishment with life imprisonment without parole. However, it was also defeated by a margin of about 54% against. This repeated rejection of abolition efforts highlights the complexity of public opinion regarding capital punishment in California.

Understanding Proposition 66

In contrast to Propositions 34 and 62, Proposition 66 aimed to expedite the appeals process for death penalty cases while maintaining capital punishment as an option. Passed by voters in November 2016, this measure sought to address concerns about lengthy delays in executing death sentences. Proposition 66^[5] reflects a desire among some voters to reform rather than eliminate the death penalty in California.

California Death Penalty Laws

The California death penalty laws are provided under various California Penal Codes. The main law governing capital punishment is in Penal Code Section 190^[6] which deals with association and capital crimes and the procedure for arriving at the punishment.

A number of criminal activities commonly attract the death penalty:

• First-degree murder^[7] is accompanied by special circumstances like causing the death of many people, or killing a police officer or a person during particular other crimes like robbery^[8], rape, and others.
• After conviction, the defendants undergo another procedure to come up with the verdict to either set a death penalty or life imprisonment without eligibility for parole.

The death penalty in California​ is a legal procedure and involves a number of steps and appeal and review phases. Each defendant given a death penalty has the right to appeal convictions and the corresponding penalties through various other state and federal courts. This long process may at times take several years or even decades before an execution can be affected.

Moratorium on Executions in California

In the same month of March 2019, Governor Gavin Newsom signed an executive order^[9] that halted executions in California. This order stopped all executions while serving as the governor and demanded the shutdown of the execution chamber in the San Quentin State Pen. Although this moratorium does not eliminate the death penalty itself, it influences its application in very many ways.

The hope is that the moratorium is in response to mounting concerns regarding equity and efficiency of applying the capital penalty under the criminal justice system of California^[10].

Critics have continued to observe that race and geography are skewed in California death penalty cases, resulting in an overrepresentation of minority populations and geographical areas dominated by people of color.

For instance, studies indicated^[11] that African American defendants were more likely to be sentenced to death if they kill whites than if they kill people of other colors.

Statistics on the California Death Penalty

As of late 2024, there are approximately 700 inmates^[12] on California’s death row, making it one of the largest death row populations in the United States. Execution statistics reveal that California has not carried out an execution since January 2017 due to Governor Newsom’s moratorium. Furthermore, there have been significant concerns regarding wrongful convictions; at least 235 individuals^[13] on California’s death row have had their judgments reversed since 1989.

Racial disparities continue to be a pressing issue within capital punishment cases. Research indicates that black defendants are disproportionately sentenced to death compared to their white counterparts. Such disparities raise ethical questions about fairness in sentencing practices and highlight systemic issues within California’s criminal justice system.

The debate^[14] about the morality and efficacy of the California death penalty continues. Though capital punishment has not been outlawed in California, recent advancements show that authorities, like Governor Newsom, are trying to reconsider the position of capital punishment in the state.

If Californians keep changing their views on capital punishment, future laws may alter how it is applied or even abolish it entirely. For those interested in criminal justice reform or the moral and legal issues surrounding state executions, understanding this situation is important.

If anyone wants to advocate for their rights, needs legal advice, or requires a lawyer for criminal cases, including capital offenses, it’s best to consult experienced criminal defense attorneys.

For further information on criminal defense issues or consultation from an experienced Los Angeles criminal defense attorney, please visit or contact Manshoory Law.

References