Do you know what goes on behind the scenes when a complex case is played out in the courtroom? Well, apart from the familiar figures of attorneys who prosecute or defend the defendant, there is one more very important, and, at the same time, often elusive person – the expert witness.
Equipped with unique expertise, these individuals enter the federal court in order to illuminate complex intricacies that possess the potential to greatly influence the trajectory of justice.
This article will further explore the world of expert witnesses by concerning their engagement in criminal defense, the most recent trends to affect their influence, and the ethical issues facilitating their responsible use.
What is an Expert Witness?
First things first, let’s talk about what is an expert witness. In the field of criminal defense, testifying experts play a vital role by providing the defense attorney with their extensive expertise, specialized knowledge, and comprehensive training in a particular field.
Their scientific-technical or other specialized knowledge helps simplify intricate concepts, understand the evidence, and provide pertinent insights crucial to the case. For example, a forensic expert could examine DNA evidence[1], elucidating its importance and possible constraints.
Becoming eligible as an expert witness necessitates fulfilling certain prerequisites. These individuals are required to showcase considerable proficiency within their domain, which is typically achieved through extensive academic training, comprehensive research, and substantial professional background[2].
Types of expert witnesses
Now that we understand what is an expert witness, let’s talk about some of the requirements to become one.
Legal matters regarding criminal defense frequently encompass numerous specialized fields, with expert witnesses manifesting in various capacities.
- Forensic scientists, specializing in the examination of physical evidence, such as traces, fingerprints, or samples of DNA, occupy a very important position in the interpretation of certain obtained results as well as possible constraints.
- Medical experts, including physicians as well as other healthcare providers, could be called as witnesses, giving their expert opinion and speaking for an adequate interpretation of the medical problems, traumas, and the influence of some pharmaceuticals, or other substances involved in the case[3].
- The role of mental health professionals should also be noted in legal cases where the issue of mental capacity[4] or mere intention should be resolved, and in the form of an opinion by psychiatrists or psychologists on the psychiatric status of the defendant during the period of the supposed crime.
- Individuals who possess expertise in ballistics focus their knowledge on firearms and ammunition. They cross-examine the paths of bullets, determine the weapons used, and reconstruct shooting scenes.
It should be noted that the selection of an appropriate expert witness is contingent upon the individual circumstances of each case.
Recent Developments Affecting Expert Witnesses
The field of expert witness testimony is in a state of constant evolution, as several recent advancements are influencing their position in criminal defense.
- Technological progress: The significance of digital forensics specialists is growing in tandem with the expanding influence of technology in criminal cases5 and our daily existence. These professionals examine electronic evidence such as cellphone records, computer information, and online social activity[6]. Furthermore, improvements in DNA analysis methodologies have not only resulted in the vindication of unjustly accused individuals but also continue to enhance the precision and breadth of such evidential support.
- Legal precedents: They can have an impact on the acceptability of expert witness statements, as they can establish guidelines regarding the reliability of scientific community techniques or the necessary expertise required for an individual to be considered an expert in their respective field.
- Changes in regulations: Regulatory changes have the potential to affect the qualifications, procedures, and reporting practices of expert witnesses as regulatory bodies[6] establish or revise standards governing their role.
Importance of Expert Witnesses in Criminal Defense
The impact of expert witnesses on the outcome of a trial can be considerable. They can influence the judgments of the jurors by presenting accurate and unbiased testimonies, thus affecting the understanding of complex evidence.
Many examples confirm that professional testimonies can help prove innocence or increase the severity of legal sanctions. However, to guarantee the reliability of their statements, the qualification requirements and assessments of expert testimony should be severe.
Legal Framework of Expert Testimony in California
In California, the appropriate regulations regarding expert testimony are primarily determined by the California Evidence Code, particularly, Rule 702[8]. This rule explicitly outlines the conditions under which an expert witness can be admitted as one, meaning when they possess a specific set of knowledge that is relevant to the process.
According to this rule, the expert witness’s knowledge must be special and set them apart from ordinary individuals required for all intents and purposes to make a relevant conclusion. Nevertheless, it’s imperative to look for a specialized Los Angeles criminal defense attorney to better understand this complex subject!
Expert witnesses play a fundamental role as essential connectors between the realms of specialized knowledge and the judicial setting, ensuring that the criminal justice system makes fair and well-informed decisions.
As the field of expert witness definition and testimony progresses, it is imperative to stay updated on recent advancements, uphold ethical principles, and maintain the dependability of their expertise to achieve true justice.
Reference
-
-
Manshoory, S. (2022, September 15). Understanding DNA evidence in criminal cases | Manshoory Law. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/understanding-dna-evidence-in-criminal-cases/
-
EXPERT WITNESS | Office of Justice Programs. (n.d.). https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/expert-witness-1
-
Ronquillo, Y., Robinson, K. J., Kopitnik, N. L., & Nouhan, P. P. (2024, February 12). Expert witness. StatPearls – NCBI Bookshelf. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK436001/
-
Manshoory, S. (2019, February 7). Mental illness in the criminal justice system | Manshoory Law. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/mental-illness-in-the-criminal-justice-system/
-
Manshoory, S. (2020, August 24). How is Technology Used in Criminal Justice? | Manshoory Law. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/how-is-technology-used-in-criminal-justice/
-
Digital Evidence and Forensics | National Institute of Justice. (n.d.). National Institute of Justice. https://nij.ojp.gov/digital-evidence-and-forensics
-
Law 101: Legal Guide for the Forensic Expert | Rules for Experts (FRES): 701-706 | National Institute of Justice. (n.d.). National Institute of Justice. https://nij.ojp.gov/nij-hosted-online-training-courses/law-101-legal-guide-forensic-expert/importance-case-preparation/rules-experts/rules-experts-fres-701-706
-
Rule 702. Testimony by expert witnesses. (n.d.). LII / Legal Information Institute. https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/fre/rule_702
-