Trusted Criminal Defense Attorneys In Southern California
I agree to receive promotional content and notifications from Manshoory Law Group through email or text message. For further details, kindly refer to our Privacy Policy.
You may have come across laws that allow people to get out of jail sooner than expected, due to reduced time in jail. Prop 57 is one of those laws, but it is more than a first step to getting out of jail quickly. It represents a fundamental change in California’s approach to certain crimes, while giving prisoners access to possible opportunities for a second chance outside of the parole process. If you are incarcerated or have a family member in custody, understanding Prop 57 may be very useful.
What is Prop 57 and What Does It Do?
Prop 57, formally known as Proposition 57, is a California voter initiative that was approved in 2016 to address prison overcrowding, to allow rehabilitation, and allow people a second chance after serving their sentence. Prop 57 moved from a focus on only punishing people simply for being a criminal. It addressed some of the significant issues directly related to being convicted of one.
The following are what Prop 57 applies to:
Early parole: Individuals sentenced for a nonviolent offense are now eligible for parole consideration (the time served if they have completed the maximum sentence on the primary offense).
Credit earning: Individuals can earn time off their prison sentence if they have completed educational, job, and rehabilitation programs.
Juvenile court: Prosecutorial discretion no longer exists, and certain youths who are over 14 and if they are charged in juvenile court, it is up to the judges to make the right court determination on how to process these juveniles.
If you’re not sure if your case falls under California Prop 57, don’t just guess. It doesn’t take long for laws and eligibility rules to get confusing. A quick talk with a criminal defense attorney could save you time and give you real choices. Many prisoners have already had their sentences cut short by California Prop 57, but only after they learnt how to use it correctly.
Who Qualifies for Resentencing Under Prop 57 California?
Most of the time, the Prop 57 California resentencing rules only apply to people who have been found guilty of a nonviolent felony. That sounds easy, but it can be hard in real life.
If you want to be considered for parole under California Proposition 57, here’s what you need to know:
Now things get a little tricky: just because a crime isn’t officially called “violent” doesn’t mean that someone is guilty. If the court gave the person an enhancement, a consecutive sentence, or an alternative sentence, that could affect their eligibility. So, depending on how the case was handled, someone might still not be allowed to participate.
The Resentencing Process of CA Prop 57
If you’re wondering how someone actually gets a reduced sentence, the resentencing process under California Prop 57 looks like this:
Eligibility check: Prison staff or legal representatives review the case to see if it meets the criteria.
Credit earning evaluation: The inmate’s participation in work, education, and rehab programs is reviewed. If they’ve shown good behavior and earned credits, they may be able to shorten their sentence.
Parole hearing: If eligible, the inmate gets a parole considerationhearing. A board looks at their case, behavior, and risk level.
Decision: If approved, they could be released before their full term ends.
Supervision: After release, the person is often placed under parole supervision.
This whole process depends a lot on prison records, behavior, and how much time has already been served. The longest term of imprisonment for any offense might still apply if other charges are involved, so it’s not always a clear-cut release.
Challenges and Controversies Around Proposition 57
People did not agree with Proposition 57, even though voters approved it.
One of the biggest problems is that the law doesn’t clearly define what a “nonviolent” crime is. Certain types of domestic abuse, human trafficking, and gun-related felonies may seem serious, but they are not technically considered violent crimes in California. Some people think the law is too lenient because of that.
Other worries are:
Critics say that it’s not always clear who is eligible and why.
Some people think that letting inmates out early puts communities at risk.
Not all prisons or counties follow the same rules when it comes to Prop 57 in California.
The idea that judges should be able to decide whether a juvenile should be tried as an adult has caused a lot of discussion. Some people think it’s fairer, but others are afraid it might mean shorter sentences for serious crimes.
There has also been some confusion about the rules for earning credits. How many credits can you get? Can they be taken away? What about people who are serving sentences of years to life?
The state has put out emergency rules and updates to fill in these gaps. But for families who are waiting for answers or people who are in jail, it can feel slow and uncertain.
This is why it’s important to get help from a criminal defence lawyer in California. They can help clear up any confusion and show you how these rules apply to certain situations.
Prop 57 vs. Other Criminal Justice Reforms
Prop 57 didn’t happen in a vacuum. It’s part of a bigger wave of justice reform in California. Comparing it to other laws can help show what makes it different—and why it’s still so important.
Here’s how it stacks up:
Prop 47
This law reclassified certain nonviolent felonies (like shoplifting under $950) as misdemeanors. While Prop 47 reduced charges, Prop 57 helps people already in prison get a chance at early release or resentencing.
Prop 36
This measure changed California’s “Three Strikes” law. Now, people with two prior strikes must have committed a serious or violent felony to get a third-strike life sentence. Again, it’s focused on sentencing rules—Prop 57 focuses more on parole consideration and earning credits inside prison.
AB 109 (Realignment)
This shifted the responsibility for certain nonviolent offenders from state prisons to county jails. It was meant to reduce state-level overcrowding. Prop 57 works within the state prison system to shorten sentences and ease pressure that way.
So, what’s the difference? Prop 57 is more aboutbehavioral reform, incentives, and second chances. It doesn’t just change sentences—it rewards people who are working to better themselves inside prison walls.
That’s a big reason why it’s seen as a major shift. Instead of punishing people forever for one mistake, ca prop 57offers a pathway back into society. That said, like any big change, it still needs more clarity, oversight, and support.
Why This Law Is Important Going Forward
Thousands of people are having their lives changed by Prop 57. Since it passed, California has saved millions of dollars by lowering the number of people in prison. But more importantly, the law gives people a reason to believe that things can get better and to work towards that goal.
Even for people who are serving years to life, taking part in education, counselling, and job training can help them earn credits that really mean something. Families have the hope of getting back together. People who have done the work get to come back to their communities.
But there are still problems:
Some prisoners don’t know how to apply.
Some people aren’t sure if their sentence structure is good enough.
Things are even harder because there is confusion about the full term, enhancements, and other sentences.
That’s where good legal help comes in. A qualified criminal defence lawyer in Los Angeles can break it down, look over the case details, and make sure nothing is missed.
For parents, partners, or friends who are waiting for news, it’s important to stay up to date and ask for more information on thingslike:
What is a violent felony?
How does the court handle consecutive sentences or alternative sentences for any crime other than the imposition of an enhancement?
When will the parole board look at your case?
Is it still possible for someone with more than one crime to qualify?
These are important questions, and they need clear answers.
What Prop 57 Means for You or Someone You Know
Prop 57 isn’t just a policy—it’s a second chance. It changes the rules so people who’ve made mistakes can actually turn things around. For those convicted of a nonviolent felony, it opens a door to early parole, credit earning, and a better shot at life outside prison.
Yes, it’s complex. Yes, it’s got issues. But it’s also brought real change—and it continues to evolve.
If you or someone close to you is wondering how this law applies to your case, don’t try to figure it all out alone. Our criminal defense attorneys can help walk you through it, explain the fine print, and make sure your case gets a fair look.
Orange is one of Orange County’s most community-centered, historic cities. By all accounts, it feels safe. But that doesn’t mean it’s immune to crime, and even good people can find themselves in legal trouble.
Whether you’re a long-time resident, a student, or just visiting, understanding the most common local charges helps you stay informed. Manshoory Law Group breaks down the frequent criminal charges in Orange and how they stack up against state and national trends, because knowing the local landscape can make all the difference.
What Criminal Statistics Say About Orange
So, how safe is Orange? While some analyses show Orange’s violent crime rates are comparable to the national average, the most important statistic is your personal risk. According to recent FBI data, your chance of becoming a victim of a violent crime in the city is just 1 in 466.
The picture for property crime, however, is more complex. Data shows that property crime rates in Orange track at or above the national average, and all sources confirm that your overall chance of becoming a victim of any crime is about 1 in 50.
The real takeaway is that property crime is a much more common concern than violence. This is the key to understanding the city’s legal landscape. The risks for an average resident are less about random physical attacks and more about situations involving theft, shoplifting, or vandalism. This fact directly shapes the kinds of criminal charges we see most often.
Orange vs. National Averages: How Do We Compare?
Orange’s crime rates are well below U.S. and California averages, reinforcing its safe reputation. But if the city is so safe, what’s behind these specific crimes? It comes down to Orange’s three core personalities: it’s a major traffic hub, a shopping mecca, and a college town.
DUIs: The city is surrounded by some of the busiest freeways in the country: the 5, 55, and 22 freeways. Add in the nightlife around Old Towne and the huge crowds for events at the Honda Center and Angel Stadium, and you have a perfect storm for DUI patrols, especially on feeder streets like Katella Ave.
Theft: Orange is a premier shopping hub. The Outlets at Orange and The Village at Orange attract millions of shoppers annually. With that much retail activity, accusations of shoplifting and even employee theft are statistically inevitable.
Juvenile/Underage Crimes: The presence of Chapman University and several large high schools creates a large population of young people. This leads to a natural increase in specific charges like underage drinking, using a fake ID, and minor drug offenses like possession of marijuana or unprescribed study aids.
But here’s the thing: these patterns don’t make the city unsafe. Far from it. They simply show how the city’s character influences which laws are broken and enforced most often.
Common Charges We Defend in Orange County
At Manshoory Law Group, our experience reflects these trends. We know the laws, but more importantly, we know the local situations that give rise to these common accusations.
DUI Charges (VC 23152) A DUI is the most common serious charge ordinary residents face. A conviction brings court penalties like fines and classes, plus a separate, mandatory license suspension from the DMV. A solid defense involves challenging every part of the state’s case, from the legality of the traffic stop to the chemical test’s accuracy.
Theft & Shoplifting (PC 484 & PC 459.5) Most theft charges we defend are for shoplifting. The law distinguishes between petty theft (under $950) and grand theft (over $950). For first-time offenders, especially in low-value cases, we often successfully negotiate for diversion programs that result in a full dismissal, keeping your record completely clean.
Drug Offenses (HS 11350 & HS 11377) These cases rarely involve major trafficking. More often, it’s simple possession of a controlled substance—like cocaine, mushrooms, or unprescribed pills such as Xanax or Vicodin—discovered during a traffic stop. The defense often comes down to fighting the legality of the police search. If the search was illegal, the evidence can be thrown out.
Domestic Violence (PC 273.5) This is one of the most aggressively prosecuted crimes. An accusation alone is often enough to trigger an arrest and a temporary restraining order (TRO) that can force you from your home. Police are required to make an arrest if any injury is present. These cases are won or lost on the details, so having a domestic violence attorney involved from the start is critical.
Assault & Battery (PC 240/PC 242) Reflecting the city’s low violent crime rate, most of these cases involve “simple” assault or battery. They are typically misdemeanors stemming from arguments that got out of hand. However, any violent crime conviction can have lasting consequences, making a strong defense essential.
Juvenile Charges (WIC 602) We frequently represent students from local schools, including Chapman. The juvenile system’s goal is rehabilitation, not punishment. Our focus is always on securing outcomes like diversion or deferred entry of judgment to protect a young person’s future from being defined by one mistake.
Expungements (PC 1203.4) A past criminal conviction shouldn’t be a life sentence. An expungement cleans your record, allowing you to legally answer “no” on most job applications when asked about past convictions. It’s a powerful tool for anyone trying to move forward in a competitive county like Orange.
Why Local Legal Experience Matters in Orange Criminal Cases
If you’re arrested in Orange, your case goes to the Central Justice Center in Santa Ana. Navigating this courthouse is a non-negotiable part of a strong defense. An attorney unfamiliar with it won’t understand the unwritten rules or have relationships with the specific prosecutors who handle cases from Orange.
You need an Orange criminal defense lawyer familiar with the Orange County DA’s office—one who knows their filing policies and negotiation tactics. This insider knowledge helps us build strategies tailored to the actual people who will be handling your case.
One of our most effective strategies is pre-file intervention. This means we contact the District Attorney’s office before formal charges are filed. By presenting our side of the story, witness statements, or exculpatory evidence early, we can sometimes convince them to reject the case entirely or file a lesser charge. This proactive step can end a case before it ever really begins.
Why Orange Clients Choose Manshoory Law Group
When your future is on the line, you need a law firm that understands both the law and the stakes. Here’s why clients in Orange trust us:
24/7 legal support available
Former prosecutor on your side
10+ years of courtroom experience
Multilingual legal team
Personalized, results-driven legal plans
Local reputation and knowledge of Orange County courts
Visit Our Orange Office
We are centrally located and easy to access. Walk-ins are welcome, or you can book a secure virtual consultation. Getting legal help shouldn’t add to your stress.
FAQs About Criminal Charges in Orange
What types of arrests are most common in Orange?
Mostly, it's DUIs, shoplifting, and charges related to college life. With all the major freeways and event venues, DUI stops are incredibly frequent. Because of The Outlets, theft is common. And with a major university in town, you'll see charges for things like using a fake ID or underage drinking.
Do I have to appear in court if I'm charged in Orange?
For most misdemeanors, you probably won't have to. We can almost always go to court for you so you don't have to rearrange your life or miss work. For a felony, though, the answer is yes—the court requires you to be there in person.
Can my charge be reduced or dismissed?
Yes. That is always the main goal. A good lawyer's job is to pick apart the prosecutor's case from every angle. We hunt for holes—was the police stop even legal? Was evidence mishandled? Finding those weak spots is exactly how we get charges dropped or knocked down to something less serious.
Arrested in Orange? Contact Us Today.
Don’t let a criminal charge define your future. An accusation is not a conviction. But what happens next—in the first few hours—can change everything. Call us. We get to work right away.
If you’ve heard the terms “Medicaid fraud” and “medical fraud,” you might wonder what they really mean — and who can actually get into trouble for them.
These aren’t just technical mistakes or billing errors. They’re serious offenses that can bring criminal charges, steep penalties, and even jail time.
As long as you’re a health care provider, a billing clerk, or a business owner in the medical field, it’s important to know where the line is and what’s at stake.
What Is Medicaid Fraud?
Medicaid fraud happens when someone tries to get money from the Medicaid program by lying or cheating the system.
Medicaid is a joint state and federal government program designed to help people with low incomes get medical care. Because it uses taxpayer money, it’s tightly monitored.
Here are some common examples of Medicaid fraud:
Billing for services that were never provided.
Performing unnecessary tests just to bill more.
Charging Medicaid for expensive procedures but delivering cheaper ones.
Accepting kickbacks for patient referrals.
Overbilling for durable medical equipment like wheelchairs or walkers.
States have their own medicaid fraud control units (MFCUs) that specifically look for fraud and take action. These fraud control units, MFCUs, work with federal agencies and local investigators to catch wrongdoers and recover stolen funds.
If you’re part of a state medicaid agency, you’re also under administrative rules and audits. Failing to follow administrative requirements, even by accident, can sometimes raise red flags. That’s why knowing the rules is key to keeping your practice safe.
What Is Medical Fraud (and How Is It Different)?
Medical fraud is a broader term that covers any type of fraud in the healthcare system — not just Medicaid.
It often involves private insurance companies, Medicare, or even patients lying to get care or benefits they’re not entitled to.
Health care providers inflating bills for insured patients.
Unlike Medicaid fraud, which focuses on cheating a government program, medical fraud also targets private businesses and insurance companies. Both fall under the bigger umbrella of health care fraud, and both can lead to serious charges.
So why does the difference matter? Because there are different laws applied, and the penalties can vary.
For example, the medicaid fraud control units are focused solely on Medicaid cases, while private insurers might hire investigators or work with law enforcement separately.
Who Can Be Charged with Medicaid Fraud?
You might think only doctors or hospitals get charged with Medicaid fraud — but that’s not the case. Anyone who knowingly helps commit fraud can face charges.
People who can be charged include:
Physicians and nurses: They can face charges for billing Medicaid for fake, unnecessary, or inflated treatments, or for falsifying records to get higher payments.
Office managers and billing staff: These employees handle claims and paperwork. If they alter codes, misstate services, or knowingly submit false information, they can also be held responsible.
Owners of clinics, labs, or nursing homes: Business owners who approve, encourage, or ignore fraudulent billing practices can be charged for directing or enabling fraud schemes.
Patients: Medicaid recipients who lie about income, medical conditions, or household information to qualify, or misuse their benefits, can also face serious fraud charges.
Investigators will often look at the whole chain of people involved. If you sign off on claims, even if you didn’t directly handle the paperwork, you can still be held responsible if the claims are fraudulent.
Because the federal agencies and the medicaid fraud control units work closely to investigate and prosecute, it’s important to get legal help right away if you’re accused. Speaking with an experienced criminal defense lawyer is one of the smartest first steps you can take.
Penalties for Medicaid Fraud
The penalties for Medicaid fraud can be severe. Both state and federal laws apply, and they don’t go easy on offenders.
Here’s what you might face if convicted:
Fines: These can reach into the hundreds of thousands or even millions of dollars.
Restitution: You may have to pay back every penny stolen.
Prison time: Jail sentences can range from months to years, depending on the amount and intent.
Loss of license: Medical professionals may lose their ability to practice permanently.
Bans from government programs: Being excluded from Medicaid, Medicare, and other programs can end a medical career.
Even administrative actions, like failing to follow administrative requirements, can result in heavy fines and loss of your ability to bill Medicaid. These penalties aren’t just a slap on the wrist — they’re life-changing.
Common Legal Defenses in Medicaid Fraud Cases
If you’re accused of Medicaid fraud, don’t panic. There are defenses that can help you fight the charges.
Some of the most common defenses include:
Lack of intent: Fraud requires intent. If you made an honest mistake, like a coding error or misunderstanding a rule, you might avoid criminal charges.
Insufficient evidence: Prosecutors have to prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt. If the evidence is weak, the case could fall apart.
Compliance with rules: Showing that you followed state medicaid agency rules and administrative requirements can strengthen your defense.
Improper investigation: If the medicaid fraud control unit or other investigators violated your rights during the process, evidence may be thrown out.
The right criminal defense lawyer can help you build the strongest possible case and protect your future. Acting quickly is crucial.
How to Prevent Medicaid Fraud Allegations
The best way to deal with Medicaid fraud? Don’t get caught in it in the first place.
Here are some practical steps to help you avoid allegations:
Train your staff: Make sure everyone knows what’s legal and what’s not. Provide regular updates on billing rules and compliance.
Audit your records: Review your claims and billing regularly to catch errors before the medicaid fraud control units do.
Keep clear documentation: Always document patient care and keep detailed records to back up your claims.
Consult experts: Work with lawyers or compliance officers who understand Medicaid rules.
Be transparent: If you find a mistake, report it and fix it quickly to show good faith.
Even in places like the District of Columbia, where oversight can be especially strict, taking these steps can save you a lot of trouble.
With so many moving parts — from billing for services to meeting administrative requirements — keeping your practice clean is worth the effort.
Remember, medicaid fraud control units are always watching. Staying vigilant helps protect you, your staff, and your patients from devastating consequences.
Stay Informed and Protect Yourself
Both Medicaid fraud and medical fraud are serious crimes with harsh penalties. Knowing the difference and understanding who can be charged is your first step to staying safe.
Whether you work in nursing homes, run a clinic, or handle billing, staying compliant with Medicaid and other programs is essential.
Keeping yourself informed, training your team, and staying transparent are the best ways to keep your practice and reputation intact. Fraud accusations don’t just cost money — they can cost careers. Stay proactive and protect your future.
San Bernardino is one of the largest cities in the Inland Empire, and it faces unique legal challenges. While every city has its issues, knowing what charges are most common here helps you stay informed and prepared if you ever find yourself in a difficult situation.
This post breaks down the data behind local crime, compares San Bernardino to state and national averages, and explains what you should know if you’re charged.
At Manshoory Law Group, we use our deep local experience to guide clients through even the most complex criminal cases, turning confusion into a clear plan.
Crime in San Bernardino: What the Numbers Show
The numbers tell the real story of what you’re up against.
The city-wide crime rate is 44 crimes for every 1,000 residents. For you, that means a 1 in 23 chance of becoming a victim of any crime. More than 96% of other California communities are safer.
Property crime is a huge part of the problem. Your chance of being a victim of property crime here is 1 in 30. And it’s not just minor stuff. The city has one of the highest rates of motor vehicle theft in the nation.
The violent crime rate is also one of the country’s highest. Your chance of being a victim of violence is 1 in 91. The state average is 1 in 197. That gap is massive. And yes, this includes a murder rate that is higher than most other U.S. cities.
How San Bernardino Compares to National Crime Rates
The picture gets even clearer when you put San Bernardino next to the rest of the country.
The city’s overall crime rate is 2% higherthan the national average.
Violent crime rates are 220.7% higher. This means they are more than triple what you see elsewhere.
Property crime rates are 51% higher.
This isn’t a small problem. Economic pressure and the city’s role as a huge transportation hub create a tough environment for law enforcement and residents. When you are charged here, you are part of a system dealing with a massive number of cases.
Common Criminal Charges We Handle in San Bernardino
These numbers become real police reports and criminal charges every day. From what we see fighting in the San Bernardino courts, these are the charges that fill the dockets.
DUI Offenses (VC 23152)
San Bernardino is a commuter city, and the freeways are patrolled heavily. A DUI arrest is very common. A first-time DUI is a misdemeanor, but don’t let that fool you. You’re still looking at jail time, big fines, and a suspended license. If you have prior convictions or someone was hurt in the incident, it immediately becomes a felony DUI, and the stakes are much, much higher.
Drug Possession & Distribution (HS 11350 & 11351)
California drug laws are a maze. Simple possession of a controlled substance (HS 11350) is often a misdemeanor. But police have a lot of discretion. If they decide you had the intent to sell, they’ll charge you with a felony under HS 11351. They make that call based on things like how much of the drug you had or if you had a scale. Their opinion can be the difference between a fine and prison.
Assault & Battery (PC 240 & 245(a)(1))
Simple assault and battery are misdemeanors. But the real problem here is aggravated assault under Penal Code 245(a)(1). Assault with a deadly weapon. A “deadly weapon” can be almost anything in a fight, not just a gun or knife. This is a felony, and it makes up a huge portion of the local violent crime stats.
Domestic Violence (PC 273.5)
In these cases, the phone call to the police is often enough. Once an accusation of domestic violence is made, an arrest is almost certain. If the alleged victim has any kind of visible injury—even a scratch—you will be charged with a felony for corporal injury to a spouse. A conviction means jail, probation, a year-long class, and a lifetime ban on owning a firearm.
Theft & Burglary (PC 487 & 459)
There’s a big difference here. Grand theft (PC 487) is stealing something worth more than $950. But burglary (PC 459) is about intent. It’s entering a building with the intent to commit a theft or any felony inside. You don’t have to actually steal anything. If they can convince a jury you intended to steal when you walked in, that’s the crime. And it’s a felony.
Juvenile Offenses (WIC 602)
When your kid is the one in trouble, the stakes feel even higher. The juvenile system is built for rehabilitation, not punishment like in adult court. But a conviction—called an “adjudication”—can still create huge roadblocks for college and future jobs. The goal is always to secure a real second chance, fighting to have records sealed so one mistake doesn’t define a young person’s life.
Expungements (PC 1203.4)
There is life after a conviction. A call to the court to dismiss your past conviction. It doesn’t erase your record, but it lets you legally and honestly say you were not convicted of that crime on most job applications. It’s a key tool for a fresh start.
Why Local Legal Representation Matters in San Bernardino
In a place like San Bernardino, having a local lawyer isn’t just an advantage; it’s a necessity.
Every courthouse has its own culture and unwritten rules. The San Bernardino Superior Court is an overloaded, fast-paced system. An out-of-town lawyer won’t know the prosecutors. They won’t know the judges’ tendencies. This is a home-field advantage, and you need it on your side.
They know the process. From the first day in court—the arraignment—to the pre-trial negotiations where cases are often won or lost, they know the procedures that work here.
They know the people. Knowing which Deputy District Attorney is more likely to make a fair deal—and which ones aren’t—is critical information. That’s not in a law book. It’s learned from experience.
They know the stakes. They know what a San Bernardino jury is likely to do. They know what kind of plea bargain is a good deal and what is a complete waste of your time. This knowledge is leverage.
Why San Bernardino Clients Trust Manshoory Law Group
Available 24/7: We know arrests happen at 3 a.m. We’re here when you need us.
Former Prosecutor’s Insight: Our background as prosecutors means we know how the other side thinks and how they build their cases. It’s how we find the weaknesses.
10+ Years in SoCal Courts: We have a deep, proven history of defending clients in San Bernardino and across Southern California.
Multilingual Staff: We are ready to serve everyone in our diverse community.
Personalized, Results-Driven Strategies: Your case is not a file number to us. We build a defense strategy for you and your situation.
Arrested in San Bernardino? Contact Us Today.
Just call to set something up. Legal trouble moves fast. The prosecution is already building its case. So should your defense.
Our office is right here in the community. Come see us in person, or we can set up a virtual meeting online if that works better for you.
Get immediate help from our team now.
San Bernardino Criminal Defense FAQs
What are the most common arrests in San Bernardino?
Besides DUI and domestic violence, the two big ones are aggravated assault and motor vehicle theft. Property crime and violent crime drive most of the arrests.
What court handles my criminal charges in San Bernardino?
Criminal cases are heard at the San Bernardino District of the Superior Court of California, located at 247 West Third Street.
Is it possible to reduce or dismiss charges locally?
Yes, that's the job. An attorney can file a motion to have a case dismissed if the police violated your rights. Or we can negotiate with the prosecutor to get a charge reduced—like a felony down to a misdemeanor.
Can I meet with a lawyer online or after hours?
Of course. We offer virtual consultations and we are available 24/7. Trouble doesn't stick to a 9-to-5 schedule. Neither do we.
How long will it take to resolve my case?
Anyone who gives you a quick answer is not being honest. A simple misdemeanor might take weeks. A complex felony trial can take more than a year. It depends on the facts of your case.
Superior Court of California County of San Bernardino. (2025). Welcome to the Superior Court of San Bernardino. Retrieved from https://sanbernardino.courts.ca.gov/
If someone told you falsifying documents was no big deal, they were wrong. It can get you into serious trouble fast. If you’ve been accused or you’re worried about what counts as a crime here, you’re in the right place.
Falsifying documents can be either a misdemeanor or a felony, depending on what you did and why.
Some types of forged documents carry harsher criminal penalties.
You can defend yourself with the help of a criminal defense attorney if you’re falsely accused.
Proving intent to defraud is a key part of these cases.
State laws vary, so penalties and defenses depend on where you are.
What Counts as Falsifying Documents?
Not every mistake on paperwork is a crime. But falsification of documents happens when you knowingly change, create, or use a document with the intent to deceive someone. It’s considered a type of white collar crime, often tied to fraud, forgery, or false reporting.
Some common examples include:
Altering dates or amounts on business records to hide losses.
Submitting false statements on a loan application.
Creating a false document like a fake medical note or fake ID.
Forging signatures on contracts or checks.
Making a false entry in official records to benefit yourself.
It doesn’t even have to be about money. Even a forged school transcript or fake government form can count if you intended to trick someone into believing it was real. The type of documentmatters too — falsifying a government record is often treated more seriously than a personal note.
Is Falsifying Documents a Felony Crime?
So, is falsifying documents a felony? That depends on the document, the amount of harm caused, and your intent. In many cases, it can be a felony, especially if you forged official records, caused significant financial loss, or tried to scam a government agency.
For example:
Creating or using a fake driver’s license can carry felony charges.
Changing numbers on tax returns can be a felony.
Falsely altering property deeds is almost always a felony.
But sometimes it’s a misdemeanor instead. If the falsehood is minor and didn’t hurt anyone financially, it might carry lighter penalties. Keep in mind, though, that even a misdemeanor can still mean jail time, fines, and a criminal record.
Penalties for Falsifying Documents
If you’re found guilty of falsifying, you’re looking at some pretty steep consequences. Criminal penalties vary depending on your state’s laws, but here’s what’s typically at stake:
Jail or prison time — from a few months to several years for a felony.
Those are usually harsher than for private documents. Also, law enforcement often treats crimes that involve an intent to defraud more seriously than a simple mistake.
Even something like altering a date on a form might seem harmless, but it can still violate state laws if done knowingly. The bigger the fraud or the more official the document, the bigger the punishment.
Common Defenses to Forged Documents Charges
If you’ve been accused of using or creating forged documents, don’t panic — there are defenses you can use. Working with an experienced criminal defense attorney can help you figure out the best strategy.
Some possible defenses include:
No intent to defraud — You made a mistake or didn’t realize the document was false.
Lack of knowledge — You didn’t know the documents in question were altered or fake.
Duress — Someone forced you to falsify or use the false document.
Insufficient evidence — Prosecutors can’t prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you falsified anything.
Prosecutors need to show you had the intent todeceive. If you can show you didn’t have that intent, the charges may not stick.
What to Do If You’re Accused of Falsifying Documents
Getting accused of falsification of documents can feel overwhelming, but you have options. The worst thing you can do is ignore it or try to explain yourself to police without help.
Here’s what to do:
Don’t talk to law enforcement without your lawyer present.
Gather any paperwork that shows your side of the story.
Stay off social media — anything you post can be used against you.
Follow your lawyer’s advice and keep detailed records of everything.
It’s tempting to think you can explain it away, but prosecutors will use your own words against you if you’re not careful. Having the right legal help can make all the difference between a conviction and having the case dropped.
Protect Yourself If You’re Facing Charges
Falsifying documents isn’t something you want to handle alone. The stakes are high, and a conviction can follow you for life. If you’ve been accused, work with a trusted criminal defense attorney who knows the law in your state and can protect your rights.
Take action right away — the sooner you get help, the better your chances of resolving the case on the best terms possible.
No. Sometimes it’s a misdemeanor, especially if the harm caused is small and the document isn’t official. But if you forged something serious, like a public record or financial statement, it’s more likely to be treated as a felony.
Can I go to jail for changing a date on a form?
Yes, you can — if you changed it on purpose to deceive someone, that’s a crime. Even something that seems minor, like changing a date, can violate the law if it was done with intent to defraud.
What if I didn’t know the document was fake?
If you genuinely didn’t know the document you used was false, that can be a valid defense. The law usually requires that you knowingly use or create a false document to be guilty of falsifying.
You hear about them on the news, maybe a friend whispers the term in a group chat, and suddenly the words Ghost Gun pop up in your head.
You wonder, “Is it really a big deal?” Short answer? Yes.
What Is a Ghost Gun?
A ghost gun is a firearm that skips the normal factory trail. It starts life as unfinished frames and receivers, parts that can be purchased online or at a swap meet without a criminal background check.
Using basic tools like a drill press, hand tools, or even a 3D printer, individuals can complete these parts at home. Because these firearms typically lack serial numbers, they are difficult for law enforcement to trace, placing them in what’s often referred to as the “gray market.”
Unlike a store-bought pistol, a ghost build doesn’t move through the federal regulation pipeline. The parts ship straight to your door. You handle the rest.
That secrecy boosts its appeal to hobbyists who crave DIY projects—but it also raises red flags for law enforcement agencies worried about undetectable firearms showing up at crime scenes.
A quick timeline helps:
1968: Congress passes the Gun Control Act, also known as the Control Act of 1968. This law creates the foundation for modern gun laws, requiring serial numbers on firearms and regulating their sale, ownership, and tracking.
Today: With cheaper tech and access to 3D printing files or router kits, almost anyone can build a working ghost gun at home—often in just a weekend—without going through a criminal background check or official paperwork.
So, the core test is simple: if it sidesteps a serial stamp and official paperwork, you’re likely looking at a ghost build.
Are Ghost Guns Legal?
Rules depend on state law and evolving federal law. Some states treat ghost builds like any other gun: if you’re a lawful owner, no permission is needed. Others close the door entirely, requiring engraving or banning self-made firearms outright.
In 2024, a fresh federal regulation expanded the definition of “firearm” to include unfinished frames. That shift pulled many build kits back under gun regulated status.
Every year brings a new court battle. One headline case, known as the Supreme Court ghost gun ruling (decided in 2023 and revisited in 2025), allowed enforcement of the ATF rule while lower courts fight about its reach. The decision didn’t outlaw all homemade guns, but it showed the justices take the threat seriously.
Why Ghost Guns Are a Legal Concern
No traceability: Ghost guns don’t have serial numbers, so police can’t link them to a buyer or seller. This makes it harder to solve crimes or track how a weapon ended up at a scene.
Easier transfers: Since there’s no required criminal background check, anyone—including someone banned from owning a gun—can buy or trade a kit privately with no paper trail.
Patchwork rules: One county may allow builds, the next may not. Travelers get caught off guard crossing borders.
Public safety fears: Stories of ghost builds in school shootings push lawmakers toward stricter gun laws.
Regulatory whiplash: Each new court or agency action flips requirements, leaving honest hobbyists guessing what the law requires
What Happens If You’re Caught With a Ghost Gun?
Picture getting pulled over for a broken taillight. An officer sees a firearm on your passenger seat. If that pistol has no serial number—and you’re in a jurisdiction that bans them—you face multiple charges in seconds.
Common counts include:
Possession of an unregistered firearm under the Gun Control Act (federal): Ghost guns without serial numbers may be treated as unregistered firearms, a serious federal offense that can lead to felony charges and up to 10 years in prison.
Possession of a prohibited weapon under local statutes: If your state law bans ghost guns or requires serialization, just having one—even at home—can result in criminal charges, especially if it was made after the ban.
Transportation of an untraceable weapon across state lines: Moving a ghost gun into a state where it’s illegal or lacks proper markings can trigger federal law violations and possibly lead to trafficking charges.
Penalties vary. A first violation can bring hefty fines, felony records, and even prison. Repeat offenders risk stiffer sentences.
A related supreme court ghost gun case from 2024 upheld a five-year federal sentence for trafficking unnumbered pistols across three states. Courts use that benchmark often.
Beyond prison, you’ll face:
Property seizure: Officers can take the gun plus the tools used to build it.
Long-term loss of rights: A felony blocks future firearm ownership under federal law.
Career fallout: Security-sensitive jobs may vanish overnight.
How to Defend Against Ghost Gun Charges
When charges drop, time matters. You need a battle plan and a seasoned criminal defense lawyer who knows self-made firearm cases inside out. Solid defenses include:
Challenging intent: Prosecutors must show you knowingly built or owned an untraceable weapon. If a friend left the gun in your glove box without telling you, that muddies the intent.
Questioning classification: Was the part legally a firearm? Prior to the latest rule, many 80-percent frames were considered raw metal, not guns. Your lawyer can attack unclear definitions.
Fourth Amendment fights: If police lacked probable cause, the court can toss evidence. No gun equals no case.
Grandfather clauses: Some states allow earlier builds if you mark them within a grace period. Proof of timely engraving helps.
Selective enforcement: Targeted policing—like seizing ghost builds only from one demographic—can violate equal-protection rights.
Each argument needs records, photos, purchase receipts, and expert testimony on firearms frames. Act fast, gather paperwork, and hand everything to counsel.
To learn more, watch the video where our attorney Shaheen Manshoory explains how to deal with ghost gun charges.
Preventive Tips: How to Stay Within the Law
You don’t want that jailhouse orange. Follow these steps to lower risk:
Check local rules first. Laws shift quickly. Call your sheriff’s office or read your state’s firearms code before ordering kits.
Engrave early. If allowed, mark your build with unique serial numbers within the window set by lawmakers.
Keep receipts. Document every part purchase, including lower receivers, jigs, and tools.
Store safely. Lock completed weapons in a safe. That keeps curious teens and burglars away, reducing chances of misuse.
Know travel limits. Crossing into a state that bans ghost builds can turn an ordinary road trip into a felony stop.
Stay updated. Track federal regulation changes and agency notices. Rules from the bureau of alcohol tobacco can change with little warning.
Avoid gray-market forums. Buying unfinished kits through anonymous channels heightens scrutiny. Choose licensed sellers when possible.
Consider traditional purchases. A standard shop sale requires a criminal background check, but it also protects you from surprise legal headaches.
Key Takeaway Checklist
Action
Why It Matters
Verify gun laws before you buy
Avoid instant illegality
Mark the frame
Meets many state engraving mandates
Keep build photos
Proves your timeline if new bans appear
Consult a pro
A quick phone call can save you thousands
Ghost builds sound cool on a YouTube tutorial, but they pack real-world legal heat. Stick to clear rules, mark your parts, and talk to a lawyer if you get a knock on the door. That one step can separate a hobby from a nightmare. Stay informed, build smart, and keep your record clean.
In high-stress situations where your safety—or the safety of someone else—is at risk, knowing your legal rights can make all the difference. California law does allow individuals to use force in self-defense, but only under specific circumstances. Misunderstanding when and how you can legally defend yourself can lead to serious criminal charges.
In this guide, we’ll break down the core principles of self-defense in California, including how “stand your ground” and “Castle Doctrine” laws apply, what constitutes justifiable force, and when these laws offer legal protection. Whether you’ve faced a threat or are simply looking to understand your rights, this article will help clarify what the law allows—and where the limits lie.
What are the California Self Defense Laws?
Self-defense is the act of using force to defend yourself or someone else. Using force against people is normally a crime. When you claim self-defense as a legal defense for your actions, you are admitting that you committed the crime, but did so only to defend yourself. This is a form of affirmative defense[1].
California self defense laws allow you to use force, up to and including lethal force, to defend yourself or other people. This means that if you have a reasonable belief that someone presents an imminent danger or you are in danger of being killed, you may use proportionate force to stop the threat.
Shortly, Yes. Self defense laws in California explicitly state that if you are in immediate danger, you do not have any obligation to retreat according to Penal Code 198.5[2]. Even if retreat is available and appears to be a safer option, you have the right of self-defense and are legally entitled to stand your ground against an attacker. This is the opposite of ‘Duty to Retreat’ self-defense rules. In states with a ‘Duty to Retreat’ doctrine[3], victims of violent crimes[4]are obliged to attempt any available escapes before defending themselves with force.
For example, if you are walking on the street and someone threatens you with a weapon, assaults you, or otherwise illegally uses force against you, California laws of self-defense do not require you to run away or leave the area. If you are somewhere you are entitled to be, like a public area, then you can use the necessary force to remain in that place without becoming the victim of a violent crime.
In some circumstances, you may even pursue an attacker if it can reasonably be deemed necessary to prevent their attempted crime.
Is California a “Castle Doctrine” State?
Yes. California follows the Castle Doctrine, which provides additional legal protections when defending your home. In California, like many other states, your right to stand your ground applies within your own home with additional protections. Most significantly, there is a legal presumption that you feared imminent serious injury or death. This legal principle is known as the Castle Doctrine[5].
The specifics of this California self-defense gun law differ from state to state. In California, the Castle Doctrine only applies within your home itself, not all of your property. In other words, it does not apply in your yard, driveway, and other outdoor areas.
This means that if an intruder breaks into your home, the court must assume that it was reasonable for you to believe you were in imminent danger. As a result, if an intruder forces their way into your home, your use of force, up to and including the use of deadly force in self-defense, will be given the benefit of the doubt unless contradictory evidence can be produced.
When is Self Defense Justified?
When you act in self defense, you have committed a violent crime, and you could be punished for it if you did so in a situation where you cannot claim self-defense. Some valid self-defense uses are obvious. If someone physically assaults you or someone else around you, you may use force to dissuade them from further violence or render them incapable of further violence, as necessary. Under the Castle Doctrine, uses of force against a home intruder are usually considered valid self-defense.
Outside of your home, you can generally only claim self-defense when you are acting to prevent the use or threat of violence. This means that you cannot use force to prevent larceny-theft[6], such as someone stealing a package from your porch. However, if someone commits robbery, this involves the use of force.
For example, when someone brandishes a weapon[7]at you or threatens to assault you if you do not hand over your possessions or vacate your vehicle. In these scenarios, the threat of violence creates a reason for you to believe that force is necessary to protect yourself from harm, which can justify your claim of self-defense.
What are the Elements of Self-Defense in California?
To successfully claim self-defense after using force against someone, you must prove that:
You reasonably believed yourself or someone else to be in imminent danger
You reasonably believed that using force was necessary to prevent harm
You did not use more force than was necessary to prevent harm
Proving these is not always straightforward, but violent crimes lawyers can help you make the best argument for your case.
Imminent Danger
Imminent danger means that there is a possibility of you or someone else being harmed, and it is happening right now. You cannot claim self-defense for an action you take pre-emptively.
For example, if someone brandishes a weapon and approaches you with it, there is an immediate threat. However, if someone threatens you with violence that will happen at a later point, such as by making a threatening phone call, you cannot use force in response to that threat alone.
You also cannot claim self-defense for an action you take in response to harm that has already occurred and is no longer happening. For example, if someone assaults you then you can defend yourself at the time, but you cannot seek them out later to attack them.
Reasonable Belief a Threat Exists
Your belief that there is a real threat can be reasonable even if the threat does not really exist. A jury will decide whether a reasonable person would have believed the danger was real if they had been in your position, with the information you had.
For example, if someone points a fake or unloaded gun at you, most people would assume that the gun is real and loaded. As a result, you had a reasonable belief that you were in imminent danger and needed to use force, even though your assumption was incorrect.
On the other hand, your belief that you are in danger can also be unreasonable. For example, if you are experiencing paranoid delusions or hallucinations you may feel that someone intends you harm, and respond with force. A reasonable person would not have believed that they were in any danger, so you cannot argue that you had a reasonable belief of the threat.
Justifiable Force
You cannot use a level of force that exceeds what is needed to stop a threat.For example, if someone shoves you, you may be justified in shoving them back to get them away from you. Responding to this assault by shooting or stabbing someone would likely be seen as an excessive force that was not needed to end the threat.
This is more complex than the initial level of violence or the type of weapon involved, however. There are many factors that can affect whether your use of force was justified.
Context matters: Your size, the aggressor’s behavior, or whether you’re defending someone else can influence what is considered proportionate. If you are outnumbered or physically outmatched, this can justify a reasonable belief that greater use of force was needed to prevent the threat. There can also be situations where a reasonable person might deem less force to be necessary, such as if you use self-defense against a minor.
What are the Limits of Self Defense?
You can only claim self-defense when you have used force to protect human life or protect a person from bodily harm such as assault, kidnapping, or sexual assault. In California, your use of force must be proportionate to the threat.
The legal right of self-defense ends when there is no longer an imminent danger. You must stop using force as soon as the threat has passed. For example, you cannot continue to hurt someone once they are restrained or unconscious, because they are not a danger to you anymore, regardless of what they did or attempted to do to you previously.
What is Imperfect Self Defense?
Imperfect self-defense means that your case does not have all three elements of a self-defense action; however, it has enough elements that you are partially excused for your crime. This can result in receiving a lesser charge, such as turning a murder charge[8] into a voluntary manslaughter charge, which carries a lighter sentence.
Can I Claim Self-Defense If I Hit Someone First?
You can claim self-defense even if you attacked first, but this places even more emphasis on the grey areas of whether your belief of danger was reasonable, and the use of force justified. For example, you could argue that someone bunched their fist and tensed as though they were going to punch you, so you acted to restrain them before they could do it.
If you have previously assaulted someone before leaving the scene and they later attack you, you can claim self-defense for using force to prevent their attack, even if you are found guilty of the initial assault.
Can you go to Jail for Self Defense in California?
Yes—if your actions fail to meet the legal requirements for self-defense or are considered “imperfect,” you can still be charged and convicted. If the jury finds that your actions were not self-defense, or were a case of imperfect self-defense, you can be convicted of a crime that carries a prison sentence. The highest charge you can be convicted of for imperfect self-defense is voluntary manslaughter, according to Penal Code 192[9], which can have a sentence of up to eleven years and a fine of up to $10,000.
Self-Defense Checklist
Before acting in self-defense, consider:
Is the threat happening right now?
Would others believe you’re in danger?
Is your response proportionate?
Has the threat stopped?
Have you been involved in a self-defense incident and need a Los Angeles criminal defense lawyer? Contact the best attorney in LA to ensure the best outcome for your case.
FAQ on California Self Defense Laws
Do I have to retreat in public?
No—California’s “stand your ground” applies anywhere you have a legal right to be
Can I protect my goods?
Yes—but only with non-lethal force. Deadly force for property alone is not justified.
Can I use force to defend my property?
Only non-lethal force is allowed to protect property. Deadly force is never justified solely for theft unless there's a threat to life.
Do I have to retreat first?
No—California does not require retreat if you're in a lawful location and face imminent harm.
Can I defend someone else?
Yes—but you must reasonably believe the other person was in imminent danger of harm.
Kardashian will face her biggest educational test yet in sitting the California state bar, which Manshoory says is “known as one of the most challenging bar exams in the country.”
Criminal law classifies crimes partly based on the defendant’s state of mind at the time of the offense. This division between specific intent crimes and general intent crimes changes how a case is handled, what defenses work, and how bad the punishment might be. Anyone facing charges needs to understand this difference.
Understanding Intent in Criminal Law
Criminal law looks at two main things: what someone did (actus reus) and what they were thinking (mens rea). California uses special jury instructions called CALCRIM[1] to explain this. Intent connects someone’s thoughts to their actions when committing a crime. It helps measure how blameworthy they are and affects both the charges they face and their sentence if convicted.
Criminal laws place intent into two main buckets: specific and general intent.
Specific Intent Crimes Explained
For prosecutors to win their case, they must prove two things: that the defendant did the act AND that they had a particular purpose in mind when doing it.
Check the law’s language. Words like “with intent to,” “knowingly,” or “willfully” mean prosecutors have to prove what the defendant was thinking, not just what they did.
Take burglary as an example[2]. Just proving someone entered a building unlawfully isn’t enough. Prosecutors must also show they entered specifically to commit theft or another felony once inside. Without that mental element, it’s not burglary.
Examples of Specific Intent Crimes
Burglary (PC 459): Unlawful entry PLUS intent to commit theft or a felony inside
Robbery[3] (PC 211): Taking property by force or fear, PLUS intent to permanently deprive the owner
Forgery (PC 470): Signing someone else’s nam,e PLUS intent to defraud
Other specific intent vs general intent distinctions appear in crimes such as theft[5], embezzlement, solicitation, conspiracy, and attempted crimes[6].
A criminal defense attorney sometimes uses the memory aid A-SPCF: Attempt crimes, Solicitation, Property felonies, Conspiracy, First-degree murder.
What are Defenses for Specific Intent Crimes?
When the law requires specific intent, these defenses can work:
Showing the prosecutor can’t prove the defendant’s state of mind
Evidence of intoxication that prevented the formation of the proper criminal intent
Mental illness that made forming specific intent crimes impossible
Defense strategy focuses on breaking the link between actions and mental state. Since prosecutors must prove both the act and the intent, creating doubt about either element of the crime can lead to acquittal.
What are General Intent Crimes?
General intent crimes only require proof that the defendant deliberately committed the act, regardless of what they intended to happen as a result.
Prosecutors just need to show that the defendant voluntarily did something against the law. Their reasons or goals don’t matter.
CALCRIM No. 250 covers these crimes, telling jurors to focus only on whether the defendant deliberately did the criminal act[8], not what they hoped would happen.
These offenses focus on the voluntary action rather than the purpose.
Examples of General Intent Crimes
Assault (PC 240)[9]: Just requires an intentional act causing fear of harmful contact
Battery (PC 242): Just requires intentional, harmful, or offensive touching
Rape: Focuses on doing the act without consent, not intent to harm
Many scholars note that specific intent vs general intent can be determined by examining the statutory language. Courts figure out which type applies based on the law’s wording and previous cases.
What are Defenses for General Intent Crimes?
Defending against these charges typically involves:
Proving a lack of voluntary action (unconsciousness, seizure)
Punishment: The former category often comes with harsher penalties
Prosecution Approach: For the more complex cases, prosecutors must prove the defendant’s purpose beyond just doing the act
Why Intent Knowledge Matters for Your Defense
Knowing whether you face specific intent crimes or general intent charges helps build the right defense. This distinction affects everything from evidence to sentencing. California courts keep refining these distinctions through their rulings. The specific intent crimes offer more defense options based on mental state. The general intent focuses mainly on whether the defendant voluntarily did the prohibited act.
If you or someone you know is facing criminal charges, intent matters; our experienced defense attorneys can assess your case and develop effective strategies based on specific intent requirements. Contact us today at (877) 511-7583 for a free consultation.
In criminal law, this defense holds true when someone acts under a false but reasonable belief, therefore influencing their mens rea¹. Whether the accused had the necessary intent to participate in illegal activity takes the front stage. Should the erroneous notion eliminate intent, a conviction could be denied. It is not like a Mistake of Law, though, since courts hardly consider ignorance of the law as a legitimate justification. Analyzing legal tactics in criminal cases depends on an awareness of this difference.
Explaining the Mistake of Fact Defense
Whether someone has criminal intent depends on their act occurring under an erroneous but reasonable assumption regarding a critical fact. This defense of error is applied in circumstances whereby the accused did not deliberatelycommit a crime.
For example, taking another person’s jacket by mistake while thinking it belongs to you lacks the intention of theft. Still, deliberately grabbing it even knowing it belongs to someone else is not allowed.
This case is more successful where conviction depends on establishing intention. When intent to act alone is enough for guilt, its effectiveness is limited. Some offenses do not allow this defense at all, as intent is not required for conviction.
The Role of the Mistake of Fact in Criminal Liability
In criminal law, the mental state² determineswhether an act was intentional or accidental. Many crimes call for proof of purpose, and this defense might refute that by demonstrating the accused lacks understanding of misconduct.
Taking an item while believing it belongs to you differs from knowingly stealing it. One involves an honest mistake, while the other demonstrates criminal intent.
Courts carefully assess fact or law distinctions³. A Mistake of Factcan excuse a crime by negating intent, but a Mistake of Law—claiming ignorance of the law—is rarely accepted. The key difference is whether the misunderstanding affects the ability to form criminal intent.
What is the Mistake of Law Defense?
This defense applies when a person commits a crime due to ignorance or misunderstanding of legal rules. Unlike other defenses that question intent, it argues that the defendant did not realize their actions were illegal.
Courts rarely accept this argument because individuals are expected to know the law. Not realizing that gambling is illegal in a certain state does not exempt someone from penalties. However, in rare cases, it may apply, such as when a government official provides incorrect legal advice that leads to unlawful actions.
In certain legal disputes, mistakes of law defensesare sometimes raised, but generally face strict limitations. Courts often require that the misunderstanding stem from official misinformation rather than personal ignorance of the law.
Do These Defenses Apply to Strict Liability Crimes?
Certain crimes do not require proof of intent; committing the act alone is enough for conviction. These offenses include statutory rape, selling alcohol to minors, and certain environmental violations.
Because mistake-of-fact defenses rely on negating intent, they are usually ineffective in these cases. A store owner who mistakenly sells alcohol to a minor using a fake ID⁴ is still liable—even if they genuinely believed the buyer was of legal age. Strict liability⁵ laws prioritize public safety over individual misunderstandings, making intent irrelevant in most cases.
Criteria for a Valid Mistake of Fact Defense
For this defense to be valid, the mistake must be both reasonable and bona fide (made in good faith). Courts consider whether a typical person in the same situation would have made the same honest mistake and whether it negates criminal intent.
A key factor is the type of crime involved. In specific intent crimes, where proving intent is necessary (e.g., theft or fraud), a mistake of fact can be a strong defense. If someone took another’s property genuinely believing it was theirs, they lacked the required intent for theft⁶.
However, in general intent crimes, where only the intent to act matters (e.g., assault), this defense is harder to use. Mistakenly striking another person under the belief they were an attacker may still lead to guilt, as the intent to strike existed, even if the reasoning was flawed.
Limitations and Challenges of the Mistake of Fact Defense
This defense does not apply when the misunderstanding is unreasonable or irrelevant to the crime. If a defendant’s belief was irrational or negligent, such as assuming an unlocked car was theirs without verifying ownership, the argument is unlikely to succeed.
One major challenge is proving that the mistake was reasonable and made in good faith. The prosecution may argue that the accused should have verified the facts before acting. Courts assess whether a reasonable person would have made the same error under similar circumstances.
Additionally, societal and legal perceptions influence how judges and juries interpret legal defenses in criminal cases. A mistaken belief that aligns with common sense is more likely to be accepted than one that appears reckless. This makes it critical for defendants to present strong evidence supporting their claims.
This defense plays a crucial role in cases where intent matters but comes with strict legal limitations. Successfully arguing it requires proving a reasonable and good-faith belief. However, courts carefully evaluate the circumstances, and a weak argument can lead to conviction.
Legal representation is essential in navigating a defense in criminal law cases. Our criminal defense attorneys at Manshoory Law can assess whether a defense of a mistake is applicable and build a strong case. Without proper legal guidance, defendants risk misinterpreting the law and facing severe penalties.
Consult a qualified lawyer today to build the strongest defense and secure the best possible outcome.
We use cookies to personalize content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyze our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our advertising and analytics partners who may combine it with other information that you’ve provided to them or that they’ve collected from your use of their services. Agree
Privacy & Cookies Policy
Privacy Overview
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
