Trusted Criminal Defense Attorneys
In Southern California

I agree to receive promotional content and notifications from Manshoory Law Group through email or text message. For further details, kindly refer to our Privacy Policy.

Call or text Today for a
Free Case Analysis

(877) 977-7750

Select Page
Detention vs Arrest: What is the Difference?

Detention vs Arrest: What is the Difference?

When the police come knocking, it is natural for an individual to feel a rush of stress and anxiety as to why they want to talk. Potentially, a police officer isn’t interested in talking but rather in taking an individual into custody for a crime. When police are involved, they have the power to detain an individual, arrest them, or detain them followed by an arrest. There is a difference between detention and arrest, and it is critically important that a defendant who finds themselves in a potential criminal situation understand their rights.

Having the support of an experienced and skilled criminal defense attorney providing you with legal counsel when you are being questioned by the police[1] is critical to protecting your civil liberties. Defendants who are arrested and convicted of crimes face far-reaching disadvantages in life and reduced opportunities.

When you are in police custody, connecting with the Los Angeles criminal defense attorneys at the Manshoory Law Group is essential to the success of your case. While providing officers with your identifying information is advisable, answering any other questions they have about a crime should not be done without the support of your attorney.

How are Detention and Arrest Different?

Detainment and arrest are connected but are different. A detainment may not result in criminal charges, whereas an arrest will. You may be detained[2] because an officer suspects that you know about a crime or that you were connected to a crime, and their suspicion is reasonable and valid.

The officer can hold you for some time while they determine if their suspicion is backed up by evidence. This may come by way of questioning you or by an investigation, or both. In situations where the offense isn’t too serious, detention may not take too long. However, when detainment is in response to a major criminal event, detention can be prolonged.

Regardless of the crime you are suspected of being associated with, if law enforcement lacks sufficient information to link you to it, you will likely not be arrested and instead released. However, if further investigation uncovers evidence that establishes probable cause, you may be arrested at a later time. If you are arrested outright, both an investigation and questioning will typically follow.

In both detention and arrest situations, officers will try to use their position to find out as much information as possible to use against you either so they can arrest you or so they can support your charges.

In California, detention and arrest are two distinct legal concepts, each with specific implications for the individuals involved and the rights they have in each situation. Here’s a breakdown:

What is Detention in California?

  • Definition: A temporary hold or stop by law enforcement to investigate possible criminal activity. Detention does not mean you’re under arrest.
  • Legal Standard: Requires reasonable suspicion, which means the officer has specific, articulable facts suggesting you may be involved in criminal activity.
  • Duration: Generally brief; usually limited to the time needed to confirm or dispel the officer’s suspicions. This is often referred to as a Terry Stop[3] (from Terry v. Ohio).
  • Examples:
    • A traffic stop.
    • Being stopped on the street for matching the description of a suspect.
  • Your Rights:
    • You are not free to leave but are not under arrest.
    • Officers can ask questions, but you are not obligated to answer beyond providing basic identifying information (e.g., name).
    • If an officer begins a pat-down search (frisk), it must be based on a reasonable belief that you might be armed and dangerous.

What is Arrest in California?

  • Definition: A formal action where law enforcement takes you into custody because they believe you have committed a crime.
  • Legal Standard: Requires probable cause, which means the officer has enough evidence to reasonably believe you committed a specific crime.
  • Duration: Typically leads to being taken to jail or another detention facility, where you may be booked and held until released on bail, your own recognizance, or after seeing a judge.
  • Examples:
    • Being handcuffed and taken to jail after an officer finds drugs during a search.
    • Being arrested on a warrant for failing to appear in court.
  • Your Rights:
    • You must be informed of your Miranda rights before any custodial interrogation begins (e.g., “You have the right to remain silent…”).
    • You have the right to an attorney.
    • You may be searched incident to the arrest (e.g., for weapons or evidence).

Key Differences

Aspect Detention Arrest
Legal Standard Reasonable suspicion Probable cause
Duration Brief (minutes) Extended (hours or more)
Freedom to Leave No, but not taken into custody No, taken into custody
Rights Involved Limited (e.g., no Miranda required) Full rights, including Miranda

Can You Be Detained Without Being Told Why?

An arrest can happen without detainment, meaning if you commit a crime that an officer witnesses, they can arrest you on the spot. If a judge issues an arrest warrant[4] against you, an officer will use this legal document to find you and arrest you. Only in an arrest does an officer have to read you your Miranda Rights. Your Miranda Rights[5] detail your right to remain silent. While you won’t be reading your Miranda Rights during a detainment, you still have the right to remain silent, and you should know this so you don’t feel pressured to answer questions that could ultimately hurt your case.

Contact an Experienced Criminal Defense Attorney

Whether you are just detained or are arrested, it is important that you don’t self-incriminate or jeopardize your case in any way. The Los Angeles criminal defense lawyers at the Manshoory Law Group will preserve your legal rights and see to it that you are treated fairly. Contact our lawyers at Manshoory Law Group today to schedule a free case evaluation at 877-977-7750.

References

  1. Manshoory, S. (2021, July 16). Your rights when questioned by police but not charged. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/you-dont-have-to-answer-the-lapd-questioning-you-when-you-are-not-being-arrested/
  2. Federal Law Enforcement Training Centers. (n.d.). Terry Stop update. https://www.fletc.gov/sites/default/files/imported_files/training/programs/legal-division/downloads-articles-and-faqs/research-by-subject/4th-amendment/terrystopupdate.pdf
  3. U.S. Department of Justice. (1999). Annual Report FY 1999: Chapter 5. Retrieved from https://www.justice.gov/archive/ag/annualreports/ar99/Chapter5.pdf
  4. Manshoory, S. (2019, October 22). What are the different types of warrants? Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/what-are-different-types-warrants/
  5. Manshoory, S. (2022, November 8). What are your Miranda rights? Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/what-are-miranda-rights/

Criminal Law 101: What is “Contributing to The Delinquency of a Minor”?

Criminal Law 101: What is “Contributing to The Delinquency of a Minor”?

Penal codes and their complexities in criminal law may be complex to understand, particularly if the focus is on certain crimes such as “contributing to the delinquency of a minor.” This term can be regarded as legal and bears an important legal meaning, especially for adults dealing with children. This blog seeks to explain what this offense entails, the legal aspects of this offense, the possible consequences, and the possible defense that any accused person could put forward.

What is Contributing to the Delinquency of a Minor?

Contributing to the delinquency of a minor involves actions[1] by an adult that cause or encourage a minor—anyone under the age of eighteen—to engage in unlawful behavior. This may include providing alcohol or drugs to minors, encouraging truancy, or promoting other illegal activities. In California, this offense is primarily addressed under Penal Code Section 272[2], although other legal codes may also apply.

This law is designed to protect minors from harmful influences and negative behaviors by holding adults accountable for their actions. For example, if an adult buys an item and urges a minor to steal it or provides substances prohibited for minors, they may be charged with contributing to the delinquency of a minor. Importantly, an adult doesn’t need to directly cause a minor to commit a crime; even encouraging situations that lead a minor to unlawful behavior can result in charges.

Key Legal Elements for a Contributing to Delinquency Charge

To successfully prosecute someone for contributing to the delinquency of a minor, certain key legal elements must be established:

  • Act or Omission: The defendant must have done an act or omitted to do something he was required by law to do.
  • Causation: The act or omission must have led to, or contributed to, the continuance of the child as an object of severance of their legal right to live with and be supported by their parents, or encouraged the becoming of a delinquent child.
  • Intent: The prosecution should prove beyond any reasonable doubt that the defendant did the act cited with general criminal intent or criminal negligence.

These elements highlight that even unintentional actions can lead to serious consequences if they encourage a minor to engage in delinquent behavior.

Is Contributing to the Delinquency of a Minor a Felony?

In most jurisdictions, contributing to the delinquency of a minor is classified as a misdemeanor. However, certain aggravating circumstances can elevate the charge to a felony. For example, if the adult’s actions cause physical harm to the minor, the charge may be increased and lead to more serious penalties.

In California, Penal Code Section 272 typically classifies this offense as a misdemeanor, carrying a potential penalty for contributing to the delinquency of a minor of up to one year in jail and/or fines up to $2,500.

How Cases of Contributing to a Minor’s Delinquency are Prosecuted?

Cases of contributing to a minor’s delinquency are typically prosecuted by local district attorneys, who evaluate the facts to determine if there is sufficient basis for filing charges. To secure a conviction, the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that:

  • Earlier, the defendant omitted or neglected to perform some duties.
  • This omission or action contributed to or encouraged the minor’s delinquent behavior.

Moreover, the witnesses that the prosecutors usually rely on are competent eyewitnesses, police reports, and other available evidence[3]. It drastically shifts the balance of proof on them because their allegations can change the life of the accused as well as the minor.

contributing to the delinquency of a minor

Punishment for Contributing to the Delinquency of a Minor

Punishment for contributing to the delinquency of a minor differs depending on the jurisdiction and actual circumstances of a case. Generally speaking:

  • Misdemeanor Charges: These may attract a prison term of up to one year in county jail and/or fines of up to $2,500.
  • Felony Charges: These can be raised due to aggravating circumstances (as in if it results in harm), and can include increased imprisonment periods and stiffer penalties.

Besides imprisonment and monetary penalties, individuals convicted may also be ordered to serve probation [4], perform community service, and, if necessary, attend counseling sessions.

Defenses to Contributing to the Delinquency of a Minor

Individuals charged with contributing to the delinquency of a minor have several potential defenses available:

  • Mistake of Age: If an adult genuinely believed the minor was over the legal age (e.g., eighteen), this would provide a defense.
  • Lack of Intent: Proving there were no intentions or knowledge about encouraging delinquent behavior may decrease charges.
  • False Accusations: Situations where the child makes up stories can also be valid if supported by evidence.
  • Insufficient Evidence: Charges may be dismissed if the prosecutor cannot prove all necessary elements beyond a reasonable doubt.

These legal issues require the hiring of an experienced criminal defense lawyer to handle them.

Criminal Defense for Contributing to the Delinquency of a Minor Cases

Such charges involve prosecution for allegedly encouraging juveniles to commit crimes [5], and anyone charged with this should hire a lawyer immediately. A qualified attorney can provide valuable insights into:

  • The gray areas of the local laws about juvenile offenses.
  • Possible bargains that could reduce the repercussions of such pleas.
  • Tactics in the creation of an effective defense based on the facts of the case.

A professional attorney will review every detail of the case, including the evidence that may be produced by the prosecution, and defend the rights of the accused in a trial. 

Knowledge of contributing to the delinquency of a minor is crucial for any person having contact with children – as parents, tutors, neighbors, etc. This offense operates as both a preventive measure and a punitive one, aiming to prevent minors from participating in unlawful acts while restricting adults’ authority over them.

The consequences of being charged with this crime can be harsh and lifelong, hence the need to prevent and be informed. If you hear that you or someone you know may be charged with such an offense, consulting an experienced lawyer is key to successfully coping with such cases.

Juvenile delinquency laws, while primarily focusing on the legal protection of minors from abuse, also emphasize the adult’s role in ensuring youths do the right thing rather than making wrong choices easy to achieve. These laws encourage the growth of healthy childhood and youth environments, shaping responsible citizens for the future.

References

  1. Parents’ criminal liability for acts of minor children: Current status of California Penal Code Section 272 | Office of Justice Programs. (n.d.). https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/parents-criminal-liability-acts-minor-children-current-status

  2. Manshoory, S. (2023, May 2). What is forensic evidence and its use in criminal trials? Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/challenging-forensic-evidence-in-criminal-trials/

  3. Parker, D. (2024, February 9). What is the difference between parole and probation? Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/difference-between-parole-and-probation/

  4. Manshoory, S. (2023, December 7). When can juveniles be tried as adults in California? Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/when-can-juveniles-be-tried-as-adults/

Possession of a Controlled Substance in California: Drug Possession Laws and Penalties

Possession of a Controlled Substance in California: Drug Possession Laws and Penalties

Drug possession in California can lead to jail sentences and other penalties. The actual consequences depend on many factors, such as the type of drug in question, your intentions with it, quantity, etc. If you’d like to learn more about the possession of a controlled substance and subsequent consequences under California drug laws, check out the article below!

What Is a Controlled Substance?

The term[1] controlled substance refers to a drug whose use is regulated by the law. Some substances, such as heroin and cocaine, are illegal in all situations. Others require a prescription[2], such as oxycodone and morphine.

The reason why the use of these chemicals and drugs is under strict government monitoring is potential addiction and abuse. If you are charged with possession of a controlled substance, don’t hesitate to contact our attorneys. Our team has extensive experience and expertise in dealing with drug crimes, which can help build the best defense for your case.

possession of a controlled substance

What Is Possession of a Controlled Substance?

According to California drug laws, there are two different possessions. The first one is simple possession, which indicates you had the drug for personal use. Your charges could also indicate possession with intent to sell, which implies you planned to sell the substance.

If a police officer finds you with a drug listed among the Schedule drugs[3], you’ll probably be charged with possession of a controlled substance. Simple possession could be an infraction, which means a fine is the only possible penalty. If they classify it as a misdemeanor, it could be up to a year of jail time and a fine. Depending on the substance quantity, type, and prior convictions, substance possession could be a felony[4].

If you get those charges, make sure to contact a drug crimes lawyer. A professional attorney will identify a solid defense for your case and help get the best out of the entire situation. The severest penalties for the drug possession charges California has are related to transporting and possessing a controlled substance with the intention of selling it. If you moved the drug across at least two counties, the maximum sentence is up to nine years in jail.

How Does California Classify Controlled Substances?

The United States has a Controlled Substances Act[5] on a federal level. However, the states also have the right to create lists of Schedule drugs.

According to the California Health and Safety Code, you’ll find five categories of scheduled substances:

  • Schedule I [6]. There’s no medical use for these drugs, and they come with a dangerous risk of abuse and addiction. The list includes heroin, LSD, PCP, ecstasy, and other opiates and hallucinogens. Although marijuana is in this group, lawmakers will likely remove it soon.
  • Schedule II. Amphetamine and methamphetamine, as well as their precursors, are in this group [7]. You’ll also find Vicodin and morphine, which can be bought with a prescription.
  • Schedule III [8]. The Schedule 3 drugs have some medical use but also a moderate risk of abuse and addiction. They include ketamine, testosterone, dronabinol, etc.
  • Schedule IV. Xanax is a controlled substance in this group, as well as valium and phentermine. The medical community approves using these drugs, but only with a prescription.
  • Schedule V. These have the lowest abuse and addiction risk and wide use in the medical community. Motofen, Lomotil, and even some cough medications are in this group.

california drug possession laws

What Are the Penalties for Drug Possession in California?

The penalties vary on the type and quantity of the drug, your intent with it, and other aggravating circumstances. For example, the penalty for possession of drug paraphernalia in California could be up to six months of jail time. You might be eligible for a diversion program[9] depending on your specific case.

Penalties for Possession of a Controlled Substance

The only way you could legally have a controlled substance on you is if you have a valid prescription and the amount within the specified range. Otherwise, you could be facing a charge for drug possession under the California drug laws.

Depending on the details, you could be facing charges for the following:

  • Actual possession. It happens when you have the drug on you. The police often find it in someone’s pockets or even shoes.
  • Constructive possession. You were driving your car and had the drug in the compartment by the passenger’s seat. That means you exercised control over it and could access it easily. The same applies to keeping the drug in a gym locker. If it’s reasonable to assume it’s yours, you could face charges for constructive possession[10].
  • Joint possession. It happens if multiple persons have access to the drug. For example, joint possession of drugs occurs at parties or when two people are driving in a car. If nobody wants to admit the drug is theirs, everyone involved gets a joint possession charge.

drug possession

Penalties for Possession of Marijuana

You can legally possess up to 28.5 grams[11] for recreational use in the State of California. The only condition is that you need to be at least 21 years old. It’s also unlawful to possess marijuana on K-12 school grounds[12] while classes are in session.

Depending on the offense, possessing marijuana could be an infraction or misdemeanor[13]. The fines range from $100 to $500, and other penalties include community service, drug counseling, and jail time.

Possession of Concentrated Cannabis

According to California drug possession laws, you can legally possess up to eight grams of cannabis concentrate for recreational use[14]. But if you use medical marijuana, you aren’t subject to this limit. So you don’t have to worry about the quantity you have on you, but it’s important you have a valid prescription.

If you are a recreational user with more than eight grams of concentrated cannabis on you, that qualifies as a misdemeanor. The law states you can get a $500 fine and six months of jail time.

If you had concentrated cannabis with intent to sell it, it’s still a misdemeanor[15].

However, the offense could be upgraded to a felony on these grounds:

  • You had at least two prior misdemeanors for a similar crime.
  • The buyer for the cannabis you wanted to sell is less than 18 years old.
  • You have a prior conviction for a sex crime, violent, or another serious felony.

juvenile drug possession california

Is Drug Possession a Felony in California?

Drug possession could be an infraction, misdemeanor, or felony.

The charge you’ll be facing depends on many factors, including:

  • Substance type. If you were caught with a Schedule 1 drug, it increases the odds of receiving a felony charge.
  • Drug quantity. The acceptable limits vary on the substance. But it’s not only about going above the lawful limit but how far you go. Possession of a controlled substance in a large quantity has more chances of ending up as a felony than owning only a small amount of the drug.
  • An intention to sell the drugs. The lawmakers could see that as a danger to the community. Depending on the amount, you could face drug trafficking charges[16].
  • Other circumstances. If you were resisting an arrest or committed a violent crime[17], it could worsen your situation.

How Long Do You Go to Jail for Drug Possession?

If you face a misdemeanor, the maximum punishment is 12 months in jail. For possession of marijuana, the offense is punishable by up to six months of jail time. Juvenile drug possession California charges could only be for an infraction. Defendants under 18 will probably face a $100 fine, community service, and drug counseling.

It’s only if you committed a felony that you can get a bigger jail punishment than 12 months. Prior convictions[18] could make your next charge a felony. Alternatively, an intent to sell the drug leads to higher sentences. Finally, transporting a controlled substance is a felony. You could face up to five years in a state prison only for that offense.

What Is Proposition 47?

The voters passed the Proposition 47 referendum in 2014. Some call it the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, and its main idea was to re-qualify some non-violent criminal acts. From then, crimes that don’t involve violence aren’t a felony but a misdemeanor[19].

Since possession of a controlled substance is a non-violent crime, the Health and Safety Code considers it a misdemeanor. That means you can’t get more than a year in county jail. However, the misdemeanor benefits don’t apply if you had prior offenses similar to your latest one. If you are registered as a sex offender, you could end up with felony charges instead of a misdemeanor. It helps to have an experienced criminal defense lawyer in your corner if that happens. Don’t hesitate to contact our office and schedule an appointment to discuss your case.

drug possession charges california

Ban on Synthetic Cannabinoids

Near the end of 2016, the legislature passed[20] a law banning the possession and sale of all synthetic cannabinoids (such as the popular drug “Spice”).

Penalties for possession for personal use are:

  • First Offense: An infraction for the first offense ($250 fine)
  • Second Offense: An infraction or misdemeanor for the second offense ($500 and/or six months in jail)
  • Subsequent Offenses: A misdemeanor for subsequent offenses ($1,000 and/or 6 months in jail)

Additionally, the court has the authority to divert some defendants to a drug treatment program[21] in lieu of criminal charges. The sale or distribution of synthetic cannabinoids is classified as a misdemeanor subject to $1,000 fines and/or six months in jail.

Enhanced Penalties for Possession of Date-Rape Drugs

California also added a law[22] that raised the level of the crime for possession of drugs commonly associated with date-rape cases (e.g., ketamine, GHB, and Rohypnol) from a misdemeanor to a felony. There must be evidence of an intent to commit sexual assault to elevate the offense, and the new sentencing guidelines impose jail time for 16 months or two to three years.

How to Get Drug Possession Charges Dropped?

The defense will depend on your specific case. Your lawyer will assess the Health and Safety Code 11350(a) HS [23], which makes it illegal to possess a controlled substance in California. After gathering the details, they could go with these defense options:

  • The drug wasn’t yours. If it’s an option to claim the drug was someone else’s, this could be your defense.
  • You didn’t have control over it. It’s a frequent defense in cases of constructive and joint possession.
  • You had a valid prescription. If it’s not possible to prove you didn’t have a prescription, you could get the charges dropped on these grounds.
  • The drug search and seizure was illegal. If the police didn’t follow relevant procedures[24], the case would be dropped.
  • You didn’t know the drug was there. This approach might help to lower your sentence, but it rarely gets the charges dropped.

It’s vital to identify your best options against drug felony charges. That’s why you need an experienced lawyer with drug crime expertise. Our defense attorneys will listen to you carefully and analyze all details before building a case. That will ensure you have the best defense and odds of getting a positive outcome from the process.

Feel free to get in touch and schedule an appointment with our professional defense lawyers!

References

  1. What is a controlled substance? (2023, October 6). Environment, Health & Safety. https://ehs.ucla.edu/what-controlled-substance-0

  2. Manshoory, S. (2021, January 22). Possession of prescription drugs in California. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/how-to-avoid-jail-time-in-california-after-an-arrest-for-unlawful-possession-of-prescription-medications/

  3. Manshoory, S. (2019, July 11). Federal Drug scheduling System and classifications. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/federal-drug-scheduling-system/

  4. Manshoory Law Group, APC. (2022, January 17). Misdemeanor and felony possible consequences | Manshoory Law. https://manshoorylaw.com/misdemeanor-and-felony-consequences/

  5. The Controlled Substances Act. (n.d.). DEA. https://www.dea.gov/drug-information/csa

  6. Manshoory, S. (2022, January 18). What is a schedule 1 drug? Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/what-is-a-schedule-1-drug/

  7. Preuss, C. V., Kalava, A., & King, K. C. (2023, April 29). Prescription of controlled substances: benefits and risks. StatPearls – NCBI Bookshelf. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK537318/

  8. Manshoory, S. (2020, January 30). Schedule 3 Drugs: charges, penalties and defense. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/schedule-3-drug-charges/

  9. Manshoory, S. (2019, July 29). New diversion program for criminals in California. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/new-diversion-program-for-criminals-in-california/

  10. constructive possession. (n.d.). LII / Legal Information Institute. https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/constructive_possession

  11. Office of Non-Public Education. (2009). State regulation of private schools. U.S. Department of Education. https://www.ed.gov/sites/ed/files/admins/comm/choice/regprivschl/regprivschl.pdf
  12. Parker, D. (2024, March 7). Infraction vs Misdemeanor: What’s The Difference? | Manshoory Law. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/infraction-vs-misdemeanor/

  13. Department of Cannabis Control – State of California. (n.d.). California’s cannabis laws. Department of Cannabis Control. https://cannabis.ca.gov/cannabis-laws/laws-and-regulations/

  14. Manshoory, S. (2016, December 19). Misdemeanor, felony and “Wobbler” offenses in California. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/misdemeanor-felony-and-wobbler-offenses-in-california/
  15. Manshoory, S. (2022, January 27). Can a plea deal turn a drug trafficking charge into a simple possession charge? Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/can-a-plea-deal-turn-a-drug-trafficking-charge-into-a-simple-possession-charge/
  16. Manshoory, S. (2022, December 16). What would be considered a violent crime in California? Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/violent-crimes-in-california/
  17. Manshoory, S. (2017, February 13). How do my prior convictions affect my current case? | Manshoory Law. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/the-impact-of-past-convictions-on-current-prosecutions/
  18. Manshoory, S. (2021, January 27). How to reduce felony to misdemeanor in California: Prop 47. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/prop-47-could-reduce-your-sentence-after-a-california-theft-charge/
  19. Synthetic Drugs (a.k.a. K2, Spice, Bath Salts, etc.). (n.d.). The White House. https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/ondcp/ondcp-fact-sheets/synthetic-drugs-k2-spice-bath-salts
  20. Manshoory, S. (2022, February 22). What is Court-Ordered Rehab, and how does it work? Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/what-is-court-ordered-rehab/
  21. Lackey. (n.d.). AB 46 Assembly Bill – Bill analysis. http://leginfo.ca.gov/pub/15-16/bill/asm/ab_0001-0050/ab_46_cfa_20150413_092522_asm_comm.html
  22. Manshoory, S. (2019, June 20). California search and seizure laws. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/california-search-and-seizure-laws/

Understanding the Legal Boundaries: Is Brandishing a Weapon Illegal?

Understanding the Legal Boundaries: Is Brandishing a Weapon Illegal?

Brandishing a weapon is a significant legal issue for attorneys representing clients in various jurisdictions, including California. Penal Code Section 417 (PC 417) outlines the parameters and consequences associated with this offense. This overview aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of the legal implications surrounding brandishing a weapon, enhancing the knowledge of practicing attorneys in this area of law.

What Does “Brandishing a Weapon” Mean?

As an example of a legal definition of the term brandish, it should be noted that brandishing is the exhibition or display of a weapon, such as a handgun or another form of deadly weapon, in a way that threatens or intimidates someone. This is the definition of brandish as it should exist under PC 417 [1], and it therefore occurs in a “rude, angry or threatening manner” and is observable to another person.

A distinction must be drawn between carrying or displaying a weapon and its brandishing, which would be beyond the pale for lawyers. Carrying the weapon may, in appropriate circumstances, be lawful especially where carried with the permit to carry it as a concealed weapon, but brandishing a weapon involves an intent to frighten or intimidate others. This can be useful to separate the ability to determine whether an individual’s conduct is within the meaning of the crime of brandishing.

Brandishing a Weapon

Legal Consequences and Penalties of PC 417 Brandishing a Weapon in California

Violations of PC 417 carry severe legal consequences. Penalties for brandishing a weapon vary depending on the weapon brandished, as well as the circumstances under which the act takes place.

Misdemeanor vs. Felony Offenses

  • Misdemeanor Penalties: Typically, illegal possession of a weapon [2] is a misdemeanor. Some possible penalties include up to six months in county jail, in addition to fines up to $1,000. Of course, the weapon being a firearm may make the penalties more severe.
  • Felony Charges: If the individual brandishes a firearm in the presence of an officer or near a school, for example, the charges would become felonies. For PC 417, a felony conviction [3] will mean serving lengthy periods in state prison, one to three years. The existing sentences are enhanced with more prior convictions [4] or when the action inflicted great bodily injury.

Determinants in Plea and Charge Penalties

The context surrounding brandishing a weapon will determine the severity of the penalty. For instance, people committing crimes in public, or where the victims just so happen to be children, can get more severe sentences. The criminal defense lawyer must consider all these contextual factors when they advise the client on the charge related to brandishing.

Difference Between a Deadly Weapon and a Firearm

The definition of deadly weapons[5] as against firearms must form a legal analysis.

  • Deadly Weapons: Any object is a deadly weapon if it could when used with an intent to cause injury or death, result in the latter. Such weapons include knives, bats, and even household implements when used aggressively.
  • Firearms: A firearm is a weapon that expels projectiles by explosive force. Firearms are held up to higher standards in California law because they are dangerous weapons capable of inflicting grievous injury or death.

Legal practitioners have to tread very carefully in these definitions when handling cases involving allegations of brandishing a weapon as it has affected the nature of charges filed as well as the potential defenses available.

Assault with a Deadly Weapon vs. Brandishing

The difference between assault with a deadly weapon and brandishing is some grounds for criminal defense:

  • Assault with a Deadly Weapon: This crime entails proof that a person had an intention to cause or inflict a threat of causing harm with a deadly weapon. Also, it entails making an actual threat, which is an attempt or actual infliction of injury on another person.
  • Brandishing: In this case, brandishing does not require a criminal intent to inflict harm but is instead addressed towards an exhibition or demonstration of displaying the weapon menacingly. A defendant may be convicted of brandishing a weapon regardless of their criminal intent to utilize the weapon against another person.

This is an important difference in the eyes of defense attorneys when attempting to represent their clients accused of either of the crimes.

Crimes Related to the Brandishing of a Weapon

Certain offenses are closely related to brandishing a weapon, and legal professionals should be aware of these for comprehensive case preparation:

  • Criminal Threats: If explicit threats accompany the act of brandishing, additional charges with severe sentencing may apply.
  • Unlawful Use of a Deadly Weapon: This charge arises when a weapon is displayed or used without legal justification.
  • Assault Charges: If brandishing a weapon occurs during an altercation with intent to threaten or harm, assault charges [6] may also be filed.

Understanding these related offenses enhances an attorney’s ability to develop well-rounded defense strategies for clients facing multiple charges linked to brandishing.

Legal Defenses to Brandishing a Firearm

The following are some of the available defenses for the person charged under PC 417 for brandishing a weapon:

Self-Defense or Defense of Another Person: If he fairly believed that he was likely to suffer imminent serious bodily harm or imminent death, the person will be able to argue that their actions were justified under the precept of self-defense or defense of another. This defense must be proven as establishing the reality and imminence of the threat involved.

Lack of Intent: Evidence that it was not in fact an act meant to terrorize can sometimes be crucial. Thus, for example, a person who threatened or waved a weapon during an argument might assert this as a reasonable defense for the crime of waving a weapon.

Mistaken Belief: When the accused acted within his perception of what he thought was sanctioned under the law but was mistaken as to the facts surrounding the incident—this may significantly lower liability.

A professional criminal defense lawyer has a great role to play in the argumentation of such defenses, critically analyzing evidence and establishing reasonable doubt about the claims of the prosecution. Their technical expertise is critical in navigating very intricate legal settings that accompany accusations of brandishing.

Since complexity is thus mandated among lawyers on account of the critical aspects of the brandishing of a weapon provision under California law, the case can range from a misdemeanor with a minor jail term to a serious felony, in light of other important considerations such as circumstances and previous convictions. Notions of understanding the involved codes and how defenses might be applied amid all this enable attorneys to better represent their clients in more complex brandishing allegations cases.

For those seeking professional guidance on brandishing or related legal matters under California law, it is essential to consult a highly qualified attorney. Our lawyers at Manshoory Law are eager to help with your difficult situation. Get more information or seek professional advice about charges for brandishing as well as other related cases by contacting our office for professional guidance specific to your case.

References

  1. Manshoory, S. (2016, August 29). California concealed carry laws and regulations. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/concealed-weapons-and-californias-complex-set-of-regulations/

  2. Manshoory, S. (2016, December 19). Misdemeanor, felony and “Wobbler” offenses in California. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/misdemeanor-felony-and-wobbler-offenses-in-california/

  3. Manshoory, S. (2017, February 13). How do my prior convictions affect my current case? | Manshoory Law. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/the-impact-of-past-convictions-on-current-prosecutions/

  4. Manshoory, S. (2020, December 28). What is the Difference Between a Simple Assault and an Aggravated Assault in California? Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/what-is-the-difference-between-a-simple-assault-and-an-aggravated-assault-in-california/

What is Employee Theft and What to Do if Accused of Stealing at Work

What is Employee Theft and What to Do if Accused of Stealing at Work

Employee theft is when a member of staff steals, uses, or misuses company property without the express permission of their employer. Besides cash, employee theft can cover the stealing or misusing of supplies, products, personal data, or time. Employee theft applies to misuse of time if you are accused of altering timekeeping records to receive pay for hours you did not work.

What Is Employee Theft? Is Employee Theft a Fraud?

Employee theft is a crime where the employee commits an offense by stealing property, money, or resources from their employer. This can involve stealing cash, inventory, supplies, or even time by falsifying work hours or productivity. Misappropriation may include breaches of confidential information or any form of intellectual property. Employee theft is viewed as a serious offense and hence grounds for job termination, criminal charges, and financial losses to the business.

Some forms of employee theft are considered fraud. These include embezzlement, billing payroll and expense schemes, time theft, and supplying proprietary information to competitors.

accused of theft by employer

What is the Punishment for Employee Theft?

If you are convicted of employee theft charges, at a minimum you will be expected to pay back the value of what you were accused of stealing at work. There will also be further penalties depending on the value of the stolen assets.

If the theft is valued at $1000 or less then the crime will usually be classed as petty theft. This is a misdemeanor crime punished with a small fine and jail time of up to a year. Larger sums are classed as grand theft, which is a felony that comes with more prison time and a larger fine. Serious grand theft felonies can result in a sentence of 20 years or more, but this would be very unusual for an employee theft case.

What Does Accused of Stealing Time at Work Mean?

Being accused of stealing time at work means an employer believes you have been paid for hours you didn’t actually work. This could involve clocking in early, leaving late, taking extended breaks, or falsifying work hours. Time theft is considered a serious offense, as it impacts company productivity and finances. If accused of stealing time at work, it’s important to review your time records and understand the company’s policies. In some cases, it may lead to disciplinary action, termination, or legal consequences.

In California, stealing time at work—often referred to as “time theft” [1]—can lead to various consequences depending on the severity of the offense and the employer’s policies. Some common punishments include:

  • Disciplinary Actions: Verbal or written warnings are common initial steps.
  • Termination: Employers may fire the employee for violating company policies.
  • Wage Deductions: Employers might adjust or withhold pay for unworked hours.
  • Legal Consequences: In severe cases involving fraud, employees could face civil lawsuits or even criminal charges for theft or fraud.

Employees accused of time theft should review their rights under California’s labor laws[2], as wage deductions and penalties must comply with state regulations.

Consulting with a skilled attorney can help you understand your rights and how to handle the accusation properly.

The Impact of False Accusations in the Workplace

Being falsely accused of stealing at work can create a lot of tension in your workplace. You can face a lot of stress[3]from the threat of losing your job or your reputation, as well as the possibility of police involvement. Furthermore, your every move will be scrutinized, which is why it is vital to get expert advice from a criminal defense lawyer as soon as you are accused.

How to Respond to False Accusations at Work?

  • Firstly, stay calm. Being falsely accused of stealing at work can be very stressful, but any angry or erratic behavior is not going to help your case. Everything you do at work could be brought up later, so try to carry on as normal.
  • Secondly, cooperate with the investigation. The investigation will continue whether you are present or not, so it is better to have the chance to give your side of the story.
  • At the same time, you should also seek legal advice. This will help you understand your rights during the investigation, what to expect from the process, and how best to defend yourself in your particular situation. Defending against false accusations at work can be a complex process.

A theft crime attorney can help guide you through what to do if accused of stealing at work.

accused of theft at work

Can I Sue My Employer for False Accusations?

If an employer makes a false accusation of theft, this could damage your reputation, and you can sue them for defamation of character. There are a few basic requirements for defamation of character suit[4].

  • Your employer must have made a false statement about you, and they must have published that statement. In other words, a third party who was not you or your employer must have seen or heard the false statement.
  • You must be able to prove your employer made an untrue statement of fact, rather than expressing an opinion, and that they did so knowing their statement was untrue. For example, if an employer said they don’t think you care about your job, they could defend this as a statement of opinion. If they said you are incapable of performing your job, they would need to be able to prove that you are truly unable to do your job, or they have knowingly made a false accusation at work.
  • The false accusation of theft your employer made must have caused injury to you, for example, the damage to your reputation made it difficult to get a new job.
  • Finally, the statement your employer made must not be privileged. Privileged statements such as trial and deposition testimony are protected from defamation of character suits. In some states, statements made in references between employers are considered protected statements as long as it was not made with malice.

Should You Sue A Company For Defamation of Employment Law?

If the requirements for a defamation suit are all true, you should consider suing for defamation. Doing so will not only help you recover from the financial impact of the accusation but also clear your name of wrongdoing and enable you to move on.

How to Handle False Accusations At Work

If you have been falsely accused of employee theft, stay calm, cooperate, and get expert legal advice to help you defend against false accusations[5]. False accusations can impact your career for years and clearing your name is important when you have a case for defamation of character.

References

  1. Wong, B., JD. (2024, June 15). What is time theft & how can you prevent it? Forbes Advisor. https://www.forbes.com/advisor/business/time-theft/

  2. Dir, & California, S. O. (n.d.). New labor laws in California. https://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/Garment/New-Labor-Laws-in-California.html

  3. Goguen, D. (2023, August 7). Starting a defamation of character lawsuit. www.alllaw.com. https://www.alllaw.com/articles/nolo/civil-litigation/starting-defamation-character-lawsuit.html

  4. Manshoory, S. (2024, September 21). How to defend yourself against false accusations | Manshoory Law. Manshoory Law Group, APC. https://manshoorylaw.com/blog/defending-against-false-accusations/